Moderator: Ian






triddy wrote:snapsie, I agree with pretty much everything you say, to me the film just felt...empty. I admit I haven't read the books, but I suspect I would dislike the films even more if I had. You could really feel that they had left out a lot of important stuff.
This is also the reason why I'm actually a bit curious about the american remakes - maybe, I'm just saying maybe, they'll be able to pull it off better then the swedes. Fortunately, they have at least stated that it will be new films based on the books, rather than exact remakes of the films.
Oh, and about the bisexual nature of Salander - watch film number two and you'll complain no more![]()


fish wrote:I did enjoy this film, except, I wish it had gone on for another hour to fill in all the missing gaps.
Unlike "Dragon Tattoo" which seemed to tell a complete story, "Fire" seemed to be saying "that's all you get for now, we'll tell the rest of the story in "Hornets Nest". So from that respect I can understand Triddy's "empty" comment. Also some aspects of the violence and even the sex were a little on the gratuitous side, but overall didn't detract from the film. A big plus was the continued development of the Lisbeth character and why she became the woman she did. Noomi puts in another outstanding performance.
fish wrote:The motives of the business owners were never revealed either, I mean how do they expect to make a profit by destroying a planet, and why would you put someone in charge who was unable to control the scientific and military wing of the enterprise. As for the indigines, what's the good of a technology that allows you to bring back people from the dead but not the intelligence to use it on your own people? Duurh.
The producers should remember the three golden rules next time they make a film.
Story.
Story.
Story.
triddy wrote:fish wrote:I did enjoy this film, except, I wish it had gone on for another hour to fill in all the missing gaps.
Unlike "Dragon Tattoo" which seemed to tell a complete story, "Fire" seemed to be saying "that's all you get for now, we'll tell the rest of the story in "Hornets Nest". So from that respect I can understand Triddy's "empty" comment. Also some aspects of the violence and even the sex were a little on the gratuitous side, but overall didn't detract from the film. A big plus was the continued development of the Lisbeth character and why she became the woman she did. Noomi puts in another outstanding performance.
Yeah, that sex scene in the beginning made me blush like a little prudish girlI just had to look away for a second
![]()
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest