fish wrote:bruno wrote:I've just seen Miracle at St Anna by Spike Lee
lame, lame movie
I was put off seeing it by reports that Spike seemed too intent on making it about the race issue rather than dealing with it as a wartime drama. Is that the way you saw it too, or was it just poor storytelling?

Too much of a race issue? Yes, but USA army really behaved badly with black soldiers as far as I know. They were treated worst than european colonial troops, in some respects.
Poor storytelling? also true.
This film was too many stories (black soldiers, the USA army, the italian common people, the partisans, the "regular" germans, the SS) pasted together with no harmony. I hated the little child for his exceptional bad acting, and a good half of the italian actors were no better (no guilt on Spike Lee here, most italian actors just suck). The thing about the
miracle is lame, too.
Miracle at StAnna is wrongly offending the partisans, too: Ok they were no angels, they were feared and hated by no small part of italian people because, after they ambushed german troops or fascist officials, terrible vengeance fell on common folks (with the famous 10:1 deaths retaliation rate). This is a difficult truth, rarely spoken about here in Italy, but the film doesnt tell this truth, it speaks about a traitor partisan who helps the germans, IMHO quite a rare thing, and sure not happening at St Anna. So the St Anna folks (of today) who wanted the film banned were right in my opinion. By the way massacre at St Anna was a random act of killing by retreating SS troops.
As for Renata, the italiag girl with the husband missing somewhere in Russia, which f***s with a black soldier: in a small community of that time a married woman could not flirt openly with foreign soldiers, black or not. Italian cities were a different story, with lots of famished women throwing themselves at the victors, black, white or brown they could be (and then repenting some years after when everyone pointed fingers at them, not a pleasant thing in catholic Italy), but in a small village Renata's behaviour would just make an outcast of her from the start.
Spike Lee said he's more mature in this movie, and that he could not have made something similar 10 years ago. He manages too see matters from many different point de vue, this is true. Just think about his old movie"Do the right thing" were the right thing was burning the italian pizza bakery, for sure this director has evolved a lot,

my compliments.
Ok, I don't love him. I wanted to watch Miracle at StAnna anyway because it's a rare thing someone from outside to give a damn about the war (and the civil war!) here in Italy (but the film was financed in part by italian television). Sadly, this thing sucks. It tanked at box office in the USA, some hinted at movie theaters refusing to show it, but there's no conspiration here, it just sucks.