by Ian » Mon May 27, 2013 10:18 am
Doctor Who - I threw on The End of Time last night but turned it off after 10 minutes on the grounds that it's bloody awful. Even the voiceover at the start is hilariously badly written ("Everyone had bad dreams... but they forgot.. because they must... except for that guy... but he can't remember it much either..."). I ended up watching The Hungry Earth 2parter.
To be fair, it's not very good, but it's watchable enough and doesn't really go downhill until the second part. The NuSilurians are hilariously bad. It would be unbearable as a Tennant story, and as a series 7 story, but this is series 5, so Smith is still fresh and quirky and a breath of fresh air and hasn't yet been caricaturized in a series of irritating tics, and its Amy and Rory (before they were messed up by the ludicrous series 6 arc) rather than the personality vacuum that is Clara. It's worth watching for the regulars alone. That said, while its passably entertaining there's no getting around the fact that there's just no reason for this story to exist, given that it's just a complete rehash of a story that was done 100,000,000 times better 40 years earlier.